role of the indifferent esthete, it is really the best possible time for most writers--the sheer variety of stances, the multiplicity of "styles" available to the serious writer, is amazing. Those who are bewildered by so many Make no mistake, this is grim, harrowing and hard-hitting - all the more so that though first published in 1974, almost 50 years later we're still struggling with the same issues of racial injustice and incarceration. Indeed, one of the technical flaws of the book is that acute analyses of structural/institutional racism have to be placed in the mouth of 19 year old Tish when it's clear that this is Baldwin's own voice speaking to us with clarity and lyrical power: 'the kids had been told they weren't worth shit and everything they saw around them proved it. They struggled, they struggled, but they fell, like flies, and they congregated on the garbage heaps of their lives, like flies.' On August 29, 2017, Stephan James was set to star. [5] In September 2017, KiKi Layne and Teyonah Parris were also added, with Layne in the female lead. [6] [7] I think it was disappointing for me to discover that even a man who was a minority in two significant ways would still feel very “male” in his depiction of women.

This isn’t a long book, though it took me days to get through. It’s clear James Baldwin is a talented writer, but for me, If Beale Street Could Talk is a three star read, and the third star is strictly for the quality of the writing. I do plan to watch the movie soon (the trailer is what initially peaked my interest in this story) and hope I will like it more than the book. A second narrative line unfolds at the same time as the first, as Tish recalls the beginnings of her relationship with Fonny. She describes their noticing each other as children, their growing closeness as teens, and the moment when they both realized that their connection went deeper than either had believed. As she recalls their life together, Tish also describes Fonny’s passion for creating art out of wood or stone; the intensity of their sexual relationship; and how a friendly white landlord made it possible for them to start thinking about their future as a married couple. I never felt invested in any of the characters - Yes, there was racial injustice and it wasn’t fair these two families had to endure this challenge, but it was hard for me to feel for them - I remained disconnected throughout the book. I also truly disliked the abrupt, unfinished ending. I’m fine with an ending that leaves some elements of a story open to interpretation - After all, life is rarely neat and tidy, but this one genuinely felt abandoned. Kroll, Justin (September 13, 2017). "Barry Jenkins' New Film Finds Lead in Newcomer Kiki Layne (EXCLUSIVE)". Variety . Retrieved October 19, 2017.

Wikipedia citation

Regina King's performance received widespread critical acclaim and earned her the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress.

Tish reveals that Mrs. Hunt and Fonny's sisters are "fair skinned," which makes them different from Fonny and Frank. Mrs. Hunt used to be very beautiful when she lived in Atlanta, and she still carries the vestiges of that beauty with her. The fact that Mrs. Hunt and her daughters have lighter skin than Tish causes Mrs. Hunt to look down on Tish. On that Sunday, Mrs. Hunt gives Tish a smile and tells her she looks pretty for church, but Tish knows that she does not truly mean it. I sought out this book because I had seen Barry Jenkins's (Moonlight) film adaptation a few months ago (it gets a general release soon). I was curious about the rapturous, romantic tone of the movie. Why wasn't there more about the false charge? What happened to the racist cop? Written and set in the 1970s, “If Beale Street Could Talk” might as well be set now, because this is the kind of story that we read about in the news all too often: and just as in real life, there is no perfect resolution to this tale of injustice, prejudice and broken homes. Before I started reading James Baldwin's novel titled If Beale Street Could Talk I found it curious that the book was written about a Beale Street in New York City while the location of the movie was the Beale Street in New Orleans. A search for Beale Street in Google Maps revealed a dozen or more cities that have a Beale Street. All this piqued my interest in Baldwin's book and provided fodder for enthusiastic conversations with my wife.

Need Help?

Thompson, Anne (October 10, 2018). "Annapurna's Stunning Shakeup: What the Hell Is Megan Ellison Doing?". IndieWire . Retrieved October 10, 2018. Tish moves on to discuss speaking in tongues or being possessed by the Holy Ghost at this church, wondering if it will happen today. She notes that this doesn't often happen in her church, because they are more "respectable" and "civilized" than the Sanctified church. When they enter the church, the congregation's heads turn to watch them. Tish notes that she does not remember what color Mrs. Hunt's dress was anymore, but that it stands out in the darkness of the church. The way that Mrs. Hunt enters the church affects Tish: "She was saved the moment she entered the church, she was Sanctified holy, and I even remember until today how much she made me tremble, all of a sudden, deep inside" (24). Mrs. Hunt marches Tish and Fonny to the front and center pew and they all sit down.

It's an important book as well: a relatable story about systemic racism and the ripple effects of oppression, “a bottomless cruelty, a viciousness cold and icy.” In a bar, Frank and Joseph discuss how the former is worried about paying for a child and Fonny's legal expenses, but Joseph convinces him that they will be able to provide for their grandchild the same way they provided for their own children. Morales, Wilson (November 20, 2017). "Exclusive: Diego Luna Joins Barry Jenkins' Love Story "If Beale Street Could Talk" " . Retrieved November 20, 2017. Reviewing the novel in The New York Times in 1974, the novelist Joyce Carol Oates described the book as "a moving, painful story" but "ultimately optimistic. It stresses the communal bond between members of an oppressed minority, especially between members of a family," offering I have finally seen the film adaptation! I went to a screening last Saturday with a friend. Here are some thoughts, which I shared in the comments section in response to Nicole:Baldwin destroys all the machinery of his country: a corrupt justice; a racist police force; a hypocritical society. Very little is saved from his mordacity. Not everything is bad. There are good people, very good people, who take care of others. One of the most terrible, most mysterious things about a life is that a warning can be heeded only in retrospect: too late." who have, typically, been victimized by whites and are therefore likely subjects for a novel. The work contains many sympathetic portraits of white people, especially Fonny's harassed white lawyer, whose position is hardly better

It’s a theme that recurs in his writing. But when you put it to him, that he has never succumbed to that, never despised himself, he agrees that you may be right. And that maybe it is partly because at the age of 14, for more than three years, he was a preacher and a young man to whom many people listened, and therefore a very special cat. Someone once said to Baldwin, and he reports it in Nobody Knows my Name – “Be careful what you set your heart upon, for it will surely be yours”. Well, he goes on, “I had said that I was going to be a writer God, Satan and Mississippi notwithstanding, and that colour did not matter, and that I was going to be free.” He made it. But sometimes, as you talk to him, he wants you to know that isn’t quite everything.

If Beale Street could talk

A little bit later in the book, I noticed another reference to a song. This song was Ben E. King's Spanish Harlem. The text had been: "...'a rose in Spanish Harlem.' He grinned again. 'Next week, I'm going to get you a rose for'..." So here we are, James Baldwin. I think it's true that Taylor is more identifiable with other writers like Rooney and Cusk, and funnily enough, I likened Taylor's novel in my own review to Normal People. I'm not giving myself points here, but merely realising how bizarre it is to compare Taylor to Baldwin when the former is a contemporary writer. But anyway. Told in Tish’s voice, the story of how her and her family try to free Fonny is endlessly tragic, but also, somehow, a beautiful love story. Tish is strong and resilient, but also prudent. She is well-aware that the nightmare she is in is neither uncommon nor is it going away easily. Her family, a tight-knit group of imperfect but loving people who will try anything to help, is a stark contrast to Fonny’s, whose father is the only one who takes a part of fighting for the young man’s freedom – the very religious but heartless mother and sisters echoing Baldwin’s previous work, where characters are devoted to their Church but not to their family and community. The first recording of Beale Street Blues was made by Prince's Band, and it was released on May 24, 1917. (This, of course, wasn't the Prince you all know and love.) Kroll, Justin (July 10, 2017). " 'Moonlight' Director Barry Jenkins Sets Next Movie (EXCLUSIVE)". Variety . Retrieved July 10, 2017.